Estimate check: the arithmetic, and the difference from what you authorized
Two calculators. The first rebuilds an estimate's total from its parts, labor hours, rate, fees and tax. The second shows how far an invoice is from the amount you authorized, beside the rules some example states set.
Assumptions behind the estimate check
- Labor cost is labor hours times the shop's hourly rate, the way the FTC's Auto Repair Basics and MOTOR's labor guide describe it. Many shops charge book (flat-rate) hours from a guide, not the hours the work actually took.
- Tax is applied as you enter it: one rate on parts, one on labor. States differ on whether labor, diagnosis and fees are taxed; the rates on your shop's own paperwork are the ones to use.
- Diagnosis and other fees are added as entered, without tax. If your shop taxes them, the difference shows against the printed total. Some states bar a generic shop supplies line and others require it as a dollar amount; Reading a repair estimate has the examples.
- The calculator checks arithmetic. It does not say whether a price is fair or whether a charge is allowed.
How far the invoice is from what you authorized
Enter the amount you authorized (in writing, or noted from a phone call) and the invoice total. The calculator shows the difference in dollars and percent. It does not say whether a difference is allowed: that depends on your state and on what you authorized.
Six state examples
Examples only, read from each state's statute or agency page on 2026-11-01; the full table, with when a written estimate is required, is on Estimate terms. Ask the authority
| State | Charges over the estimate without your approval | Source |
|---|---|---|
| California | None above the estimated price without your consent | BAR, Write It Right |
| New York | None above the estimated price without your permission | NY DMV |
| Florida | $10 or 10 percent, whichever is greater, but not over $50 | Fla. Stat. 559.909 |
| Michigan | 10 percent or $50, whichever is less | MCL 257.1332 |
| Massachusetts | The shop must ask before charging more than $10 above the estimate | Mass. consumer guide |
| Washington | Up to 110 percent of the written estimate, sales tax excluded | RCW 46.71.025 |
Both calculators check arithmetic. They do not say whether a price is fair, whether a line is needed, or whether a charge is lawful where you live. For a bill you dispute, start with handling a repair that went wrong.